Group member not visible in group when offline (#434)

Unknown opened 4 years ago

Describe the bug All group members are not visible in group member list , when a particular user is offline

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

Create a group,
add some user to group and all invited users are joined
Suppose total group member list is 5
when a user goes offline , he disappears from group members list

Is there any setting needs to enable ?

Unknown commented 4 years ago

Which server (software or service domain) do you use?

Unknown commented 4 years ago

Thanks for quick reply ,

I checked with sure.im and tigase.im . I also checked with local host ejabberd server

Unknown commented 4 years ago

If you are referring to the list of participants of the MUC room visible in the UI of SiskinIM, then there is nothing to change there as this list presents a list of active and joined occupants. By default MUC kicks users out of the room when they are disconnected and after reconnection their clients joins the room again.

Unknown commented 4 years ago

@faraan it's worth mentioning that we in Tigase are dedicated to bring newer, state of the art form of group conversations powered by MIX to the XMPP ecosystem: https://tigase.net/tigase-im-mix/.

With MIX channels you won't have an issue with member disappearing from a list of room members depending on it's connection status (and it will solve more issues). Server wise it's already available on xmpp.cloud/tigase.im/sure.im and in our clients it's in current test versions, which should be released soon. For legacy clients without MIX support it would be still possible to connect to MIX channels using translation layer (MIX-MUC, implemented in Tigase XMPP Server already)

I do encourage you to try them out :-)

Unknown commented 4 years ago

@hantu85 thanks , yes I am referring to the list of participants of the MUC room.

@woj-tek Ok thanks , Sure I will check , so mix will work with any custom server (any specific configuration needed) of only with xmpp.cloud/tigase.im/sure.im .

Unknown commented 4 years ago

@woj-tek Does MIX branch code have all MIX-MUC features ? I will check the MIX branch code also

Unknown commented 4 years ago

MIX branches are already merged to master branch, so all MIX features are already part of a TestFlight build which soon should be released as official release.

However, MIX is quite a new specification and server which will need to host your channels (equivalent of a MUC room) needs to support this new sepecification.

Unknown commented 4 years ago

@faraan regarding support - MIX is relatively new spec (only 4-ish years) but it's adoption was slow. You can test it on xmpp.cloud/tigase.im/sure.im and if you want you can deploy Tigase XMPP server (https://github.com/tigase/tigase-server/) to your own instance (maybe even with docker for convenience: https://github.com/tigase/tigase-xmpp-server-docker)

Unknown commented 4 years ago

@hantu85 Ok thanks , I will check master branch .

@woj-tek thanks , sure I will check tigase server , so Is tigase server available free to use in our own instance ?

Unknown commented 4 years ago

@woj-tek thanks , sure I will check tigase server , so Is tigase server available free to use in our own instance ?

Yes, it is! :-)

It's open source and you can install it freely on your deployment (some advanced features like advanced clustering or auditlog may require license, please check https://tigase.net/pricing-xmpp for details)

	Unknown opened 4 years ago Describe the bug All group members are not visible in group member list , when a particular user is offline To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior: Create a group, add some user to group and all invited users are joined Suppose total group member list is 5 when a user goes offline , he disappears from group members list Is there any setting needs to enable ?
	Unknown commented 4 years ago Which server (software or service domain) do you use?
	Unknown commented 4 years ago Thanks for quick reply , I checked with sure.im and tigase.im . I also checked with local host ejabberd server
	Unknown commented 4 years ago If you are referring to the list of participants of the MUC room visible in the UI of SiskinIM, then there is nothing to change there as this list presents a list of active and joined occupants. By default MUC kicks users out of the room when they are disconnected and after reconnection their clients joins the room again.
	Unknown commented 4 years ago @faraan it's worth mentioning that we in Tigase are dedicated to bring newer, state of the art form of group conversations powered by MIX to the XMPP ecosystem: https://tigase.net/tigase-im-mix/. With MIX channels you won't have an issue with member disappearing from a list of room members depending on it's connection status (and it will solve more issues). Server wise it's already available on xmpp.cloud/tigase.im/sure.im and in our clients it's in current test versions, which should be released soon. For legacy clients without MIX support it would be still possible to connect to MIX channels using translation layer (MIX-MUC, implemented in Tigase XMPP Server already) I do encourage you to try them out :-)
	Unknown commented 4 years ago @hantu85 thanks , yes I am referring to the list of participants of the MUC room. @woj-tek Ok thanks , Sure I will check , so mix will work with any custom server (any specific configuration needed) of only with xmpp.cloud/tigase.im/sure.im .
	Unknown commented 4 years ago @woj-tek Does MIX branch code have all MIX-MUC features ? I will check the MIX branch code also
	Unknown commented 4 years ago MIX branches are already merged to `master` branch, so all MIX features are already part of a TestFlight build which soon should be released as official release. However, MIX is quite a new specification and server which will need to host your channels (equivalent of a MUC room) needs to support this new sepecification.
	Unknown commented 4 years ago @faraan regarding support - MIX is relatively new spec (only 4-ish years) but it's adoption was slow. You can test it on xmpp.cloud/tigase.im/sure.im and if you want you can deploy Tigase XMPP server (https://github.com/tigase/tigase-server/) to your own instance (maybe even with docker for convenience: https://github.com/tigase/tigase-xmpp-server-docker)
	Unknown commented 4 years ago @hantu85 Ok thanks , I will check master branch . @woj-tek thanks , sure I will check tigase server , so Is tigase server available free to use in our own instance ?
	Unknown commented 4 years ago @woj-tek thanks , sure I will check tigase server , so Is tigase server available free to use in our own instance ? Yes, it is! :-) It's open source and you can install it freely on your deployment (some advanced features like advanced clustering or auditlog may require license, please check https://tigase.net/pricing-xmpp for details)